How Do You Price a Home on Hamilton Mountain When Nearby Sales Are All Over the Place?

How Do You Price a Home on Hamilton Mountain When Nearby Sales Are All Over the Place?

Two bungalows near yours sold for $650,000 and $750,000. Does that put yours at $700,000? Before I’d suggest a list price, I’d want to know what buyers got for that extra $100,000. One home may have had a garage, a second bathroom and a finished basement, while the other was mostly original. Those differences tell us more than the average of the two sale prices.

Start with the homes your buyer would also consider

If you’re selling a three-bedroom bungalow on Hamilton Mountain, I’d start with nearby bungalows of similar size and condition. Then I’d look at the differences a buyer would notice during a showing. Does yours have a private driveway? How much of the basement can someone actually use? Does the house back onto a busy road or sit on a quieter street?

A recent sale a few streets over may be a better comparison than the house next door. I’d give it more weight if the layout, condition and parking are closer to what you’re selling.

Use recent sales and active listings together

Recent sales help establish a likely sale price range. Active listings show what buyers can choose from today. Both matter when you decide where to list.

Say the closest sales support a range of $685,000 to $715,000. If there’s a similar home currently listed at $699,000 with an extra bathroom and a garage, I’d want a clear reason for asking more. If your home has the deeper lot and a better layout, we can look at whether recent sales support putting a premium on those features.

Agree on what would make you revisit the price

Before listing, I’d show you which sales carry the most weight, what else is available and what would make me reconsider the asking price. For example, if buyers are booking showings but consistently choosing a similar home with more usable space, we can look at what that home offers and whether the price gap makes sense. If showings are slow, I’d look at how the listing is being presented and where it sits against the current competition.

If you’re thinking of selling on Hamilton Mountain, send me your address. I’ll walk you through the sales I’d use to price your home and explain why they’re relevant. You can also review my low-commission selling services and see how my buyer rebate works if you’re buying your next home too.

Stephen Paige, Broker of Record | REALTOR® since 2007